Buying Secondhand Power Tools Without Buying Junk
I paid $120 for a Delta contractor saw at an estate sale in March, put $31 into an arbor bearing and $24 into a decent blade, and it has cut every piece of salvaged oak I have sold since.

I paid $120 for a Delta contractor saw at an estate sale in March, put $31 into an arbor bearing and $24 into a decent blade, and it has cut every piece of salvaged oak I have sold since. The same month I paid $40 for a random orbit sander that turned out to have a scored armature, which is a repair nobody does for less than the price of a new sander. One of those purchases was research and the other was tuition.
My ledger says I have bought 34 used tools in three years for $2,180 and written off four of them. That is a 12 percent loss rate, which I will take happily against buying new. The difference between my good buys and my bad ones was never luck. It was whether I spent five minutes checking the three things that cost money to fix.
The five minute inspection
Bring an extension cord. Half the tools I look at are in a garage with no live outlet nearby, and a seller who says it ran fine last year is telling you what he remembers, not what the tool does.
- Spin the shaft or the chuck by hand before power goes near it. You are feeling for grit and for play. A smooth shaft with a faint whisper is fine. A gravelly rotation means bearings, which is cheap. Side to side wobble at the spindle means a bent shaft or a worn housing, which is not.
- Run it for a full thirty seconds, not three. Motors that are about to fail often sound acceptable cold. Listen for the pitch dropping as it warms, and put your hand near the vents to check the air coming out is warm rather than hot.
- Smell the exhaust air. Burnt varnish is unmistakable once you have met it, and it means the windings have cooked. Walk away. This is the one check that saved me from a $200 mistake on a plunge router with a beautiful case.
- Pull the brush caps if the tool has them. Brushes shorter than about a quarter inch are due, and replacements run $8 to $15 for common models. Uneven wear across the two brushes points at a commutator problem instead, which is a different and worse conversation.
- Flex the cord along its whole length, especially the first eight inches out of the housing. Cracked insulation is a $14 fix on most tools and a reason to drop your offer by twice that.
- Look at the base, table or shoe with a straightedge. On a circular saw a bent shoe makes every cut slightly out of square forever, and nobody wants to true it. A six inch rule in your pocket settles this in two seconds.
Nothing in that list needs a multimeter or any knowledge of motors. It catches the failures that actually show up.
What is worth repairing and what is not
Here is the arithmetic I use standing in a stranger's garage. Brushes, switches, cords and bearings are consumables, and together they almost never exceed $45 on a hand tool. If the tool is worth more than $120 new, those faults are an argument for a lower price rather than a reason to leave.
Armatures, field coils and gear cases are the other side of the line. A rewound armature for a mid range router costs more than half the price of a new router, assuming you can find someone who still does it. Cracked cast aluminum housings can be welded, but the alignment afterwards is a gamble, and on anything that spins fast I will not take it.
Proprietary battery platforms are where most people lose money. A cordless drill for $25 looks like a steal until you learn the pack is a discontinued nickel cadmium stick and the only replacements are unbranded cells at $38 each. My rule is that I only buy cordless tools on a battery platform I already own, and I treat the tool as bare even when a pack is included.
Stationary machines flip the logic. A cast iron table saw or a 1970s drill press is mostly a lump of iron with a motor bolted on, and almost every part of it is serviceable with hand tools and a parts diagram. I pay more readily for a heavy old machine with surface rust than for a light new one with a plastic trunnion.
The advice I argue with every Saturday
Somebody at the market tells me at least once a month that old tools were built better and new ones are disposable. It is half true and it leads people into bad purchases.
Where it holds is cast iron and steel: the stationary machines above, hand planes, vises, anvils, anything whose value sits in mass and machining. Where it falls apart is anything with electronics or a battery in it, where twenty year old technology is genuinely worse, and anything whose manufacturer no longer exists.
The test that actually predicts whether a used tool was a good buy is parts availability, not age. Before I pay over $75 I search the model number plus the word brushes, and plus the word bearing, on my phone right there. If both come back with parts in stock from more than one seller, the tool has a future. If the model number returns nothing but forum posts from 2011 asking the same question, I put it down regardless of how solid it feels. A 1962 machine from a brand still selling parts is a better bet than a 2009 machine from a brand that folded.
There is a safety line I do not cross, though, and it has nothing to do with age. Missing guards on a table saw, an absent riving knife, a dead blade brake on a miter saw, a grinder with no wheel guard: these get fixed before the tool runs or I do not buy it. Guards for common models run $20 to $60 and are worth every cent. A tool that reached its fourth owner with the guard removed usually tells you how the previous three worked, and I would rather not inherit the habit.
Where the prices actually sit
Rough percentages of current new price, from my own notes across three years of buying in one metro area. Estate sales and downsizing clear outs are the cheapest at roughly 20 to 35 percent, because the family wants the garage empty by Sunday evening and is pricing from a feeling. Online marketplace listings sit at 50 to 65 percent, and the seller has usually looked up the new price, so there is less room than you hope. Pawn shops run 55 to 70 percent with no inspection time, which is the worst combination. Manufacturer refurbished, which is used in all but name, lands at 60 to 75 percent but comes with ninety days of warranty, and for a tool I plan to run every week that trade is often correct.
Bring cash in small bills. An offer of $85 in fives and tens, counted out, closes more deals than $100 by transfer, and I have had sellers take the lower number purely because it was in their hand. Nothing in my stall or my workshop came from paying asking price, including the bench itself, which started life as a shop counter. The right workbench height for your body matters more than where the top came from.
First jobs once it is home
Every used tool gets the same hour before it earns anything. Blow out the vents with compressed air outside, not over your bench. Check and tighten every accessible fastener, because vibration loosens them and sellers never do. Replace the blade or the bit, since a dull cutter makes a sound tool feel broken and that is how good machines get resold cheap.
Then put it where it belongs rather than on the floor, because a tool stacked on the floor gets kicked and stops getting used. My own answer was pegboard storage for a small craft corner, which cost $38 for a sheet and hooks and holds everything I reach for daily. If you are starting from nothing, the five hand tools worth buying first are a better opening purchase than any used machine.
FAQ
Is it safe to buy a used table saw?
Yes, and stationary machines are where used buying pays best, provided the guard, riving knife and blade are present or replaceable. Check that the arbor spins true and that the trunnions let you square the blade to the table. A $150 cast iron saw with a $55 guard kit beats a $300 new benchtop model on every cut I make.
How much should I pay for a used cordless drill?
Treat it as a bare tool and pay 25 to 40 percent of the bare tool price, with any included battery valued at zero. Lithium packs lose capacity whether they are used or sitting on a shelf, and a seven year old pack that holds a charge today may not in six months.
What used tools should I never buy?
Anything with a cooked motor, anything on a dead battery platform, and anything whose model number returns no parts. I also skip used oscillating multi tools, because the bearing and the blade clamp both wear and neither is usually serviceable at a sensible price.
Can I ask to test a tool before buying?
Always, and a refusal is your answer. Say it plainly when you arrange to see it, so the seller can have an outlet free, and bring your own extension cord and a scrap of wood to cut. In three years only two sellers have said no, and both tools turned out to be listed again weeks later.
More in Tools and Workspace
Tools and Workspace
Workbench Height and How to Set It for Your Body
Your lower back aches after an hour of sanding, or your shoulders burn after a session of hand planing, and you assume it is...
Tools and Workspace
Pegboard Tool Storage for a Small Craft Corner
Your tools live in a drawer, and every project starts with five minutes of digging for the small square or the right awl.
Tools and Workspace
Self Healing Cutting Mat Care So It Lasts for Years
Your rotary cutter keeps skipping threads in the same spot, and when you run a fingertip across the mat you can feel a shallow...