Art of the Craft logo Art of the CraftMade by hand, shown honestly
Woodworking

Buying Hardwood by the Board Foot Without Overpaying

The first time I walked into a real hardwood yard I asked for eight pieces of cherry, six feet long. The man behind the counter asked what thickness, rough or surfaced, and how many board feet.

A maker pulling rough sawn cherry boards from a rack at a hardwood yard with a tape measure and a tally written in pencil on the top board

The first time I walked into a real hardwood yard I asked for eight pieces of cherry, six feet long. The man behind the counter asked what thickness, rough or surfaced, and how many board feet. I said I did not know, and he said come back when you do, which stung at the time and was the most useful thing anyone told me that year. I went home, worked it out on the back of a market receipt, and came back on the Thursday with a number.

I sell salvaged furniture and scrap wood pieces at a Saturday market, so almost everything I build has to clear a price. Lumber is the line on my ledger that moves most, and the gap between buying it well and buying it badly is bigger than anything I can save on glue, finish or tools. A console table that costs me $64 in walnut and one that costs me $112 are the same table to a customer. Only one of them pays me properly.

The measurement, and why it trips people

A board foot is a volume, not a length: 144 cubic inches, which is a piece 12 inches wide, 12 inches long and 1 inch thick. The formula yards use is thickness in inches times width in inches times length in inches, divided by 144. A board 1 inch thick, 7 inches wide and 8 feet long works out to 1 times 7 times 96 divided by 144, which is 4.67 board feet.

Two things in that calculation are not what you expect. Thickness is measured as the rough thickness, written in quarters of an inch, so 4/4 means one inch and 8/4 means two inches. If you buy surfaced 4/4 stock it will arrive at 13/16 of an inch thick after planing, but you pay for the full inch, because the yard bought it and dried it at that thickness. People feel cheated by this and it is simply how the trade prices its raw material.

The second is that width is usually rounded down to the nearest inch on random width boards, which works slightly in your favour on a 7 and 3/4 inch board and not at all on a 7 and 1/8 inch one. Ask which convention your yard uses. Mine rounds to the nearest quarter inch, which is fairer and means my estimates have to be a little more careful.

What I actually pay, and for what

These are my own numbers from a yard about 40 minutes from me, for rough sawn kiln dried stock in small quantities, which means under 50 board feet at a time. A cabinet shop buying 500 board feet pays noticeably less, and that gap is worth knowing about before you assume you are being gouged.

Species, 4/4 roughPrice per board footWhat I build with it
Poplar$3.40Painted carcases, drawer sides, jigs
Soft maple$4.75Shelving and anything getting a dark stain
Red oak$5.20Repairs to salvaged oak furniture
Ash$5.60Market stall trestles, chair parts
Cherry$8.40Small tables that sell on the figure
White oak$8.90Anything that lives outdoors
Walnut$13.50Lids, trays, boxes, where a little goes far
Big box red oak, surfaced four sides$10.80 equivalentNothing, if I can help it

That last row is the one worth staring at. A 1 by 4 red oak board at the home centre near me is $19.47 for six feet. That board is three and a half inches wide and three quarters of an inch thick, which is 1.8 board feet by the pricing convention, so you are paying about $10.80 a board foot for the same species the yard sells at $5.20. You are paying for it to be straight, dry, planed and available at nine on a Sunday, and sometimes that is worth it. For a project needing 30 board feet it is $168 of difference.

The advice I would argue with

Every woodworking forum tells beginners to buy rough lumber and mill it themselves, because that is where the savings are. I have a jointer and a planer now and I still think the advice is given too freely.

Milling rough stock costs you material. A 4/4 rough board that arrives cupped and twisted gives you maybe 3/4 inch of usable thickness after flattening, and the last eighth of an inch is sawdust on your floor. Count the loss properly: on a 30 board foot order I budget 25 percent waste for defects, snipe and squaring up, which means I buy 38 board feet to get 30. At cherry prices that is an extra $67 before I have cut a joint.

If you have no jointer and no planer, the comparison is not rough against surfaced. It is rough against the hours you will spend with a hand plane and a winding stick, plus the pieces you will ruin learning. I flattened boards by hand for my first two years and I am glad I did, because it taught me to read a board. I would not pretend it saved me money. Buying S2S stock, surfaced on both faces but with the edges left rough, is the honest middle ground and usually costs 60 to 90 cents a board foot more than rough. That is the order I place most often.

The one case where rough wins outright is thick stock. If you want a finished thickness over an inch and a quarter, nobody sells it surfaced in small quantities, so 8/4 rough is your only route and you work with what you have.

Sorting the pile before you pay

Most yards let you pull your own boards from the rack. Do it, and take a tape and a pencil. I look for four things, in this order: twist along the length, which is the one defect I cannot fix cheaply; the position of the pith or heart side, because a board with the heart running through it will keep moving; end checks, which can run 8 inches in and quietly cost you a foot off each end; and sapwood, which matters on walnut and cherry where the pale edge is often half the width of the board.

Then I write a quick tally on the top board of my stack, board by board, and total it before I go to the counter. Twice I have found a 4 board foot arithmetic error in my own favour and said so, and both times the yard remembered. In a trade where supply comes down to whether someone saves you the good stock off a fresh pallet, that is worth more than $20.

One habit I skipped for too long: check the moisture before you build, not before you buy. Kiln dried stock stored in an unheated shed comes back up to the humidity of the shed, and a panel glued up at 14 percent will open a gap in a heated house. Our piece on wood moisture content and when lumber is ready to use sets out the numbers I now hold to, and a $25 pin meter has saved me two tabletops.

Where salvage beats the yard, and where it does not

I get maybe a third of my hardwood free or nearly free, from old furniture nobody wants and from a cabinet shop that lets me take offcuts over 18 inches. That wood is wonderful for small work and a trap for anything needing matched boards. You cannot build a five board tabletop from a pile of mystery oak and expect the colour to agree.

The real cost of salvage is metal and time. One staple in a reclaimed board ruins a planer knife set, which is $70 for the cheap ones on my machine, so everything gets a magnet and a careful look before it gets near a cutter. If you are picking up tools cheap to handle this kind of stock, buying secondhand power tools without buying junk covers what I check first.

The step for this week is small. Price out your next project in board feet, then phone one hardwood yard within an hour of you and ask their price per board foot on 4/4 poplar, soft maple and whichever species you keep reaching for. Write the three numbers in the front of your notebook. That one call is what turned lumber from a vague expense into a line I can actually plan around. More of this sits in the woodworking section.

FAQ

Is a board foot the same as a linear foot?

No. A linear foot is just length. A 1 by 12 board happens to give one board foot per linear foot, which is where the confusion starts, but a 1 by 6 gives half that and a 2 by 12 gives two.

How much waste should I allow when ordering?

I use 25 percent for rough lumber and 15 percent for surfaced, and more when the piece needs matched grain or long clear lengths. For narrow parts that can come from anywhere on a board, 10 percent is often enough.

Can I trust lumber prices I find online?

Treat them as a range, not a quote. Hardwood pricing moves with freight and local supply, and the spread between two yards 50 miles apart can be two dollars a board foot on the same species. Phone the yard.

Is air dried lumber cheaper than kiln dried?

Usually by a dollar or two a board foot, and it is a fair buy if you can store it indoors for several months and you accept that it has not been through the heat cycle that kills insects. For anything going into a customer's house I buy kiln dried.

AP
Arlo Pemberton

Arlo sells salvaged furniture and scrap wood pieces at a Saturday market and has priced enough handmade work to know most makers undercharge. He writes about upcycling and craft business with a ledger open beside him.

More posts by Arlo

More in Woodworking

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto